After finding Petrillos on a ""top 10"" list a few months back, we just had to try it. Our friends are all native East-Coasters, and we are forever looking for great pizza. We called blind (not having a take-out menu yet) and ordered a half-cheese/half-veggie large (which is rectangle and very large!), and a medium sausage/mushroom/olive. The take-out counter is in a separate entrance, which I love. Made it easy to pick up quickly, and they were very pleasant and helpful. The pizza had a very thick crust, which is not my favorite (do they offer a thin version?) and the mushrooms were canned - yuck! But otherwise, the sauce was tasty and not too much cheese. The crust, though on the thick side, was nicely charred and not at all soggy. Held up with all the toppings nicely. Next time, we'll ask for thin crust, and we'll try the white pizza which sounds great. We'll definitely go back, but not for the mushrooms!
Pros: Nice sauce, friendly service.
Cons: Canned mushrooms.
more