This is an easy review. Andy serves excellent ribs, chicken, sides, and desserts (when available). I've learned to ask how the ribs are - and if they say they ""just came off"", order something else. That is when the ribs are a bit.... ""al-dente"". If you like your meat to be falling off the ribs, you'll want to let them rest a bit longer. As long as they didn't ""just come off"" they will be the best ribs you ever had. Flavor and seasonings are superb.\r
\r
The sides range from amazing to outstanding. Seriously, you can't go wrong. I like the greens, you might like the redskin potato salad, someone else might prefer the slaw. They're all good. If you happen to show up when the ribs haven't set-up, order the chicken. Delicious. They also have chipotle wings on occasion, if you happen to be there when they do, be sure to order those too.\r
\r
It's easy to order more at Andy's than you can eat, so work out a strategy and eat the foods that keep best - last. For me that occasionally means potato salad or slaw for leftovers, and they're still excellent.
Pros: Food, people, rib-joint feel, Colts memorabilia, selection of hot sauces. Buffet days!
Cons: Should serve chipotle wings more often
more