I give this place only 4 stars - because I left hungry and because I couldn't order a glass of red wine for under $10 a glass. I was told that since Simpatica is associated with the Laurelhurst Market, a self contained butcher shop/restaurant, I could expect a generous serving of meat. Not true. I was hungry when I left. (I went next store to Biwa where I had a couple of hanger steak skewers for $3 each.)
The meat, was excellent, Wagyu Bavette Steak, thin slices of buttery soft and delicious meat that had been with roasted on a mesquite fire, served with an outstanding Chimichurri sauce and perfectly cooked fingerling potatoes. Can't complain about the flavor and the quality but the portion was not for the true carnivore.
The night's meal also featured two types of empanadas. One was filled with ground lamb and was outstanding. The other was butternut squash which had no additional spices to make the flavor more interesting than simple boiled squash. (Personally I would have curried it a bit - some cumin, turmeric, pepper, garlic, something along that line would have enhanced it.)
Pros: The chef comes out and explains the food you will be eating and his personal decisions on how to prepare the items. This was truly one of the highlights of the night. We learned that the provolone cheese for the salad had been cold smoked, the meat was going to be cooked on mesquite wood, the care that he would take to make our fingerling potatoes come out perfectly, and that the cinnamon on our dessert was a special natural organic type without chemical processing and that the bananas were roasted to produce a natural caramelization, no sugar added.
Overall, food is very very good. The chef's willingness to try completely different menus with weekly changes and fresh ingredients is brave and deserves our admiration and support. It is hard to cook for so many people and make sure everyone's plate is similarly served similarly done and at the right temperature.
Beware the over priced wine by the glass - $10 for Chile Merlot-Carmenere? Not sure what this particular bottle cost, but wines from Chile tend to sell retail from $10 - $15 per bottle, and probably would have been restaurant priced at about $35 a bottle. At $10 a glass - with 5 - 6 pours per bottle - they have made this into a $50 - $60 bottle. The main problem is that they didn't give me an alternative as a single diner to have an economical glass of wine with my dinner. I don't want to buy a bottle if I don't have companions to share it with and I don't want to turn my $35.00 meal into a $55.00 meal just because I want some wine to go with it. What would solve the problem would be if the restaurant would select a decent red wine that they can serve at a lower price point in a carafe as their house wine. They could have a large and small carafes.
The ambience is like dining in a farmhouse kitchen with everyone that works on the farm showing up to eat at the same time. Expect it to feel cozy. You are seated on long tables with everyone else, everyone is talking at once so it can be hard to hear what your companions are saying, but overall it feels like being part of a rollicking extended family.
Pros: Creative unique food
Cons: Small portions, over-priced wine by the glass
more