The best Restaurants in Port Jefferson Station are:

1. Colosseo Pizza & Restaurant

Rating: 4.3

Category: Pizza Restaurants

1049 Rte 112
Port Jefferson Station, New York 11776
(631) 928-4972

Love that pizza and salads More

Guest

By:

Vote

2. Pizza Carnival

Rating: 3.4

Category: Pizza Restaurants

4900 Nesconset Hwy
Port Jefferson Station, New York 11776
(631) 978-0163

Carnival's been around forever and has really good food. But I would say their pizza is average, nothing out of this world and I don't usually make... More

deb b.

By:

Vote

3. Pazzo Cucina

Rating: 5.0

Category: Pizza Restaurants

208 Route 112
Port Jefferson Station, New York 11776
(631) 473-2085

This little shop, which is located in the Blockbuster shopping center, is phenomenal. The food is amazing and very affordable. We have never had... More

deirdre c.

By:

Vote

4. Create-A-Cake

Rating: 5.0

Category: Bakeries

4880 Nesconset Hwy
Port Jefferson Station, New York 11776
(631) 473-0811

Apparently this place has really "cycled" in the past - years ago, I heard it was amazing and the only place to go; then something changed and it... More

deirdre c.

By:

Vote

5. Gilshar Greek Cafe Inc

Rating: 5.0

Category: Restaurants

1102 Route 112
Port Jefferson Station, New York 11776
(631) 473-2909

Gilshar not only has great gyros, but everything I've tried on their menu is fantastic. The hot seeded pita over Greek salad is to die for. The... More

Lisa V.

By:

Vote

6. Baskin-Robbins

Rating: 5.0

Category: Family Restaurants

1035 Rte 112
Port Jefferson Station, New York 11776
(631) 331-3131

the service was outstanding , my sons birthday was a smash , the new owners were very nice and the value was great Pros: good/ the best... More

by feralcatlover at Citysearch

By:

Vote

7. Carnival Restaurant

Rating: 5.0

Category: Restaurants

4900 Nesconset Hwy
Port Jefferson Station, New York 11776
(631) 473-9772

Carnival is my husband and my favorite restaurant! We have never had a bad dish there... The owner Nick or the manager Peter are always checking up... More

by ejjmax at Citysearch

By:

Vote

8. Station Coffee Shop

Rating: 5.0

Category: Restaurants

504 Jefferson Plz, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776
Port Jefferson Station, New York 11776
(631) 331-7323

I have been going there for years. Nothing fancy but the food is always great. Friendly waitresses. After awhile you can walk in and they already ... More

Sherri

By:

Vote

9. Thai Gourmet Food Of Thailand

Rating: 4.5

Category: Restaurants

4747 Nesconset Hwy Ste 24
Port Jefferson Station, New York 11776
(631) 474-0663

The owner artie is there often and friendly! The food is fantastic, ordered how you like it, cooked in open kitchen! Bring your own wine or... More

by ejjmax at Citysearch

By:

Vote

10. Tea Garden

Rating: 4.0

Category: Restaurants

1039 Route 112
Port Jefferson Station, New York 11776
(631) 928-1884

Located close to Meat Farm (the popular grocery place) and the even more popular DMV, the Tea Garden restaurant gives a great value for the money,... More

Dimitris P.

By:

Vote