I was always interested in trying Castaway, but was scared off by bad reviews posted online.
I have now been twice within the last few weeks (summer 2009) and both times had positive experiences.
My first Castaway experience was dinner for 4. We had friendly and attentive service and a table by the window with a lovely nighttime view of the valley. There aren't any surprises on the menu (which has been described as ""tired""), but I like to think of it as ""traditional."" We had steaks, salmon, and sea scallops. All of it was enjoyable, and everything was perfectly cooked. There was no reason to complain about anything we ordered.
My second experience was for Sunday brunch. All the standard brunch items are there (including extensive dessert options), and as good as any other Sunday brunch buffet. Sitting outside on the patio overlooking the valley added a lot to the experience.
Based on my experiences, I will happily go back to the Castaway.
Pros: Good food, great views
more