I just returned from Key west and did a 2-tank dive with Southpoint. I found the crew to be very knowledge and informative. They do assume that everyone is a seasoned diver when they allow you to book the trip. It does state that the first dive would be a wreck dive in 70-95 feet of water. Though the assume all are experienced Open or Advanced Open water divers, they don't stress it up front. They should add this, as well as a recommendation for bringing a dive watch with you as the dives are unguided (this is stated though). However, as an experienced diver, these were not issues to me and I greatly enjoyed the dives, the crew and the company.
Pros: Friendly, knowledgeable crew
Cons: Need a bit more upfront communication
more