I've lived in Pittsburgh my whole life, and I have tried Gullifty's a few times. It's absolutely horrible!! The dessert tastes like a Sara Lee frozen cake. It's dry and tasteless. The food is completely bland. Everything is OVERPRICED. And despite our server being nice, the service was really slow for a not so busy weekday night. Again, all the good reviews and awards in Pittsburgh couldn't make those desserts appetizing.
Pros: Not too busy on a weekday, lots of parking in back.
Cons: HORRIBLE food, overrated desserts. Definently awful!!!
more