This place is really different from most of the others you will find on the island. It is really trashy, in the sense that they certainly spend almost no money to make the place look nice. The dining arrangement is basically you walk up to the window and order. The prices are out of control, but the seafood is perfectly seasoned. Last time I was there, I had shrimp scampi. I got maybe 6 pieces of shrimp, they were HUGE and obviously fresh -- they were expensive but entirely worth it. There is nothing cheap on the menu, but if you're craving fresh, well-seasoned seafood, the Fishery is the place to go. It's trashy and there's no ambience or romanticism, but it's a real right-off-the-dock experience.
Pros: out-of-this-world seafood, different atmosphere, super-casual, convenient parking
Cons: unfriendly service, incredibly expensive
more