I used to love them (I was a Modern customer their first week), but no more:
1) POOR VALUE partly because no reservations and a rather cold (if funky) loud atmosphere. They're charging gourmet prices but for that I want the amenities of a fine restaurant, and I dont want to be rushed during my meal by impatient servers either.
2) UNEVEN FOOD used to show reliable care in preparation, but lately I've had food delivered cold, or sloppily assembled.
3) UNPLEASANT STAFF I waited tables, and I expect no one to fawn over me. Still, I don't like feeling like its a privelege to even be served. They've gotten snotty, but lack the fine dining chops to be so.
In short--the Modern is resting on it's laurels; there are many better choices northeast where you will feel welcome, pay less, and eat a meal of equal quality.
Pros: can be delicious, funky
Cons: rushed, uneven food, poor value
more