Having heard many raves about Sullivan's, we were eager to visit, but it must have been an off-night for them, because our entire experience was hugely disappointing.
Though we'd made reservations, we waited nearly 45 minutes to be seated. The service was excruciatingly slow and inattentive; we had a hard time even getting our waiter's attention. As for the food, we started with a delicious seafood arrangement that was fantastic! Unfortunately, all three of us ordered steak for the main course, and all three were sub-par. Each was somewhat overcooked, and the one ordered medium-rare came back medium-well! The waiter was quick to acknowledge the error and replace it, but that kind of gross oversight is unexpected from an establishment so well-known for steak.
Overall, this meal would have been disappointing for half the price at a restaurant with half the reputation.
Pros: Seafood, Atmosphere
Cons: Overcooked Steaks, Very Slow Service
more