I live in Jamaica Plain and go to West on Centre pretty often, whether it's for a nice sit down meal with friends (my favorite are the mussels) or just to chat over a martini in the lounge (the chocolate martini glass actually has a chocolate rim - yum!). They also have an expansive wine list, and the banana bread pudding is divine. Upscale casual american-type food is served, and the dining room is always packed Friday & Saturday. But reservations are accepted - thankfully! - because I've waited for a table for almost an hour before.
Pros: friendly service, lively interior, open kitchen
Cons: crowded on weekends, a bit older crowd
more