I'm a big fan of McFadden's, it's a friendly place and the prices are reasonable for the neighborhood. Their food has been consistantly good when I've been there, and the drinks are a generous pour. The menu is basic but provides all the required pub food. The service is well-intentioned, but sometimes not as efficient as one would like. The best thing about McFadden's is that they are excellent for private parties or groups -- very accomodating and will work with you to meet your needs for price and other arrangements. Very un-snooty.
Pros: friendly, close to subway, clean
Cons: iffy service
more