After reading all of the other reviews here, I can't help but feel that I'm missing something.
My wife and I have eaten here (downtown) with friends 3 times in the last 6 months. The food is good, the decor is fine, and the service doesn't suck, however, there is nothing that just blows me away (e.g. would rate a 10). I was also put off by the grossly overpriced wine list (except for the half of Ridge Monte Bello which was a great deal) and the noise level.
Too many other choices with better food and service to rate this as highly as everyone else seems to be.
more