We needed to have a new garbage disposal installed, so I called around to a few companies to get quotes. I had the bottom line cost and the Cadillac version cost. When I called Penning Plumbing Heating & Cooling, the girls wouldn't tell me how much a new disposal would cost. I told them that I wasn't interested in getting the most expensive one, I wanted on that was more of middle of the road. So I wasn't after the Cadillac version, rather I wanted something that would be good and work. We're not planning on living here for another 20 years, we'll be moving soon to a condo. However, they still wouldn't give me a price over the phone. Instead, they told me that the tech would have several types on his truck and he would go over those with me when he got here. Mainly I decided to go with them because they are a reputable company, family-owned and I'd always heard good things about them.
When the technician came out, he was a really wonderful person. He was very knowledgeable and his expertise was great. The installation and customer service was nice, and he was a fine gentleman. He removed the old disposal and it was all corroded and couldn't be saved. I knew there were disposals out there for less than $120, however he didn't have these choices on his truck, or anything besides the most expensive one. I ended up paying more than double what I'd wanted to pay. I felt like I had no choice in the matter, my old one had been removed, and wasn't in any condition to be re-installed, and he was recommending the pricier disposal. Of course the unit is truly wonderful and all he promised it would be, however hindsight tells me a lot. It became a real expense for us.
Later, we needed 3 big units installed, a hot water heater, furnace and AC unit. I called Penning to get a quote. Mr. Penning himself came out. We just felt like he wasn't forthcoming with the pricing available to us. And he didn't tell us about any rebates. Also, we felt they were priced very highly. We ended up going with another company, that was maybe half the price of them. They also helped us with the rebates, even filling them out and sending them in for us, it was great.
Because of our experience with them, we would not use them again and wouldn't be comfortable recommending them either.
more