Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse

Claim
marker

1615 Old Henderson Rd
Columbus, OH 43220

marker
(614) 442-3310
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Related categories:

Food & Dining

Photos
Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - Columbus, OH
Reviews
( 20 )
( 7 )
( 5 )
( 3 )
( 0 )

Best

My husband and I have been to the Hyde Park almost every weekend for over a year, and the food, the staff and the atmosphere are all tops. The Steak Griffin with the Cabernet Sha...

Worst

I have had better steaks at Logan's Steakhouse. The filet mignon that I ordered was not very tender at all. It was ordered medium-rare and was somewhat chewy. A young woman ...

Editorial review from Citysearch 7/25/2012

I am not a fan of this place. On two visits, I ordered my filet medium and in both case they came out rare. I had to send back and when they came out it was over cooked. There in no middle ground. Either it comes out raw or it comes out over cooked. Good place for people who like over cooked steaks. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Best In Columbus 12/7/2008

My husband and I have been to the Hyde Park almost every weekend for over a year, and the food, the staff and the atmosphere are all tops. The Steak Griffin with the Cabernet Shallot Butter and the Pretzel Bread alone make the experience worth while. Not to mention the biggest and best piece of Chocolate cake you have ever had. The Manager Scott and Chad are wonderful and if your go request Lincoln or Chris as your serves for the evening...They are the BEST!!! Pros: Everything about this place is top notch. Cons: The valet staff can be abrasive at times. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Avoid Friday nights, actually just avoid it 8/20/2008

My boyfriend and I were visiting Columbus and two locals recommended Hyde Park as they best place in town for steak. We went on Friday around 6pm and the host sat us right next to the bar which was absolutely packed with men, you can figure it out. I don't have a problem with homosexuals at all. However watching men hug and kiss for and hour during our date was less than romantic. I ordered a margarita that tasted like straight tequilla, yuck. My boyfriend ordered his steak medium and it came to us completely brown throughout. I ordered the Steak Griffin and it was not edible. There was so much peppercorn on the dish you couldn't taste the steak itself. Their au gratin potatoes were amazing as were the salads and service. In the end our meal was comped. I would not recommend this restaurant to anyone who is looking for a delicious meal or a romantic atmosphere. Pros: Decor and Service Cons: Food and atmosphere more
Reply | Report abuse |

Hyde Park - Crossroads 12/17/2007

On 12/15 we hosted a group of 8 to the Hyde Park on High Street / Cross Roads Area. The service left a lot to be desired. The waitress continously reminded us how ""good"" everything was. Be carefull for the appitizer sampler. Waitress suggested one for the table and continued to charge each couple $35 for the sampler. Prior to ordering I told the waitress I would prefer another appitizer and made it seem as if it was not an option. Not a fan of shellfish I was out my desired appitizer and $35. It must have been the waitress special of the night. Steak was cooked to order, but seasoned inconsistently, still very good. Creamed spinich was soupy and not real creamy.\r \r Atmosphere was very classy, later dinner hours were a bit loud and tables were close together. Non the less a good steakhouse atmosphere.\r \r Service leaves a lot of room for improvement, food was below expectations for a high end steak house. Pros: atmosphere and location Cons: wait staff and price more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great Atmosphere 5/30/2007

I loved the deco in the restaurant. The atmosphere was fantastic. I felt like I was at a swanky restaurant in New York city. Pros: The atmosphere was great Cons: the steak was not made according to my order more
Reply | Report abuse |

Their best steak was horrible 11/20/2006

We wanted to have a nice evening with a geat food - result my steak was burned even though I ordered it medium I berely eat it. I heard a lot of good things about this restaurant but it is overpriced and I wasn't lucky with my food in that place! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Terrific food, service and great live jazz! 9/29/2006

Wondeful! My husband and I celebrated our anniversary at the Henderson rd. location. It was our first visit there. We just finished off what was left of his huge steak with some eggs for breakfast! The atmosphere was terrific, service top notch. Lovely resteraunt and delish food; will definelty return again, if nothing else for the live jazz. more
Reply | Report abuse |

WOW 9/10/2006

I went to the high street location with my girlfriend for my 25th birthday few days ago. The place was great,real classy, service was good,our server was real friendly and accomodating, although her friend was snobby, but most importantly, the steak was AWESOME!!!! i had the ribeye, and my goodness,never had one like that before, and i've been to some of the finest steakhouses. After dinner ended, they remembered that it was my birthday, eventhough my gf told me that she booked the place 3 weeks in advance, and brought us some pie which was sweet and delicious FOR FREE...to sum it up: it was a deligthful dining experience and i'll definitely come back for lots more!!!\r WARNING: their steaks come charred no matter how you order them (rare,medium,etc) which is quite the norm at fine steakhouses, so if you don't like them charred,you might want to tell them in advance. and try their sauce toppings...the citrus sauce was great..but my favorite is to make the steak OSCAR STYLE...topped with crab meats,asparagus and bearnaise sauce... yumm.. Pros: Best steak i ever had bar none Cons: valet parkins is $5...food is pricey more
Reply | Report abuse |

High St. restaurant not worth it 7/28/2006

While in town, my husband and I took my parents to the Hyde Park on High St. The reservation was for a table by the window and a birthday. In a virtually empty dining room, we were seated in the back. The steaks came out charred (ordered rare & med rare) and the waiter was arrogant - interrupting conversation, talking right over us. No mention was made of the birthday. We've been to the Henderson Road restaurant and it was wonderful...don't know what went wrong here. Pros: attractive dining room Cons: server, hostess, bad steak prep more
Reply | Report abuse |

Very nice 7/4/2006

Been there twice.....Both times the food was excellent, service was outstanding. Times to avoid are weekend nites, and prom time....Also, if you drive a Mercedes, Lamborghini, Ferrari, BMW, or any Escalade with 24's you get to park right next to the door in a no parking section and no one says anything to you! Pros: Food, service Cons: Busy times more
Reply | Report abuse |

Best so far 2/7/2006

My first visit here was a gift from my g/f last year and it was amazing! The multi-coursed meal was beyond terrific. Every item from the iceberg salad starter to the rich chocolate dessert to end it was delicious! If I could afford $100 a day to eat there, I would. Nonetheless, I hope to visit this place many more times to come! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Charred Park Grille 11/12/2005

Hyde Park was recommended repeatedly to me, so on 2 special occasions I checked it out. The service was absolutely superb. They have great salads, bread rolls. I was, however, dissapointed with the steak. All 4 of us had completely charred steaks, even when ordered medium rare and butterflied. The steaks all lacked some taste. I may try a third time, but if its no better... there will not be a 4th. If you like charred steaks this is the place for you. Pros: service, ambience, romantic Cons: steak, expensive, value more
Reply | Report abuse |

The best in town 10/4/2005

This is hands down the best steak place in town. It was the first steakhouse I visited when I moved to Colubmus with my parents and 20 years later it is still my number one choice. Ruth's Chris, Mitchell's and Morton's can't hold a candle to Hyde Park. I reccommend it to everyone and it is always my first choice for fine dining in Columbus. The steaks are incredible, sauces and toppings fantastic and their sides are great. The wine list is excellent too. You simply can't go wrong here!!! Pros: STEAK!, Atmosphere Cons: Not One... more
Reply | Report abuse |

The standard to which others strive... 6/6/2005

This is truly one of the best Steak houses in the US (not just Columbus, OH). This is a steak house that the new, trendy, upscale, want-to-be-steak-houses come to learn lessons! They really go all out to make sure that the steak is the best to begin with and then go the extra mile to be sure that it is cooked to your specifications. They have a wonderful wine list, but last but not least, you must save room for the Creme Brulee! I wouldn't take young kids, but we take our oldest daughter since she was 8 year old and they are always very accommodating! Pros: Atmosphere, Service , Food Cons: NONE, NONE, NONE more
Reply | Report abuse |

always wonderful 12/5/2004

my husband and i aren't the richest people, but when we have the money or a special occasion we go straight to hyde park. we love the food, service, attention to detail, and the dark romantic feel. i highly reccomend hyde park, and if you're lucky, you'll run into somebody famous! Pros: food, atmosphere, service more
Reply | Report abuse |

Greatest Steak Ever 3/7/2004

After eating a steak here it is a crime to call what other places call steak. From now on Hyde Park serves steak everyone else serves dead cow meat. Pros: Good Value, Comfortable, Knowledgable Staff more
Reply | Report abuse |

Quality of steak 3/7/2004

I have had better steaks at Logan's Steakhouse. The filet mignon that I ordered was not very tender at all. It was ordered medium-rare and was somewhat chewy. A young woman was sitting at a table next to us and had also ordered a filet mignon, and also was complaining about the tenderness of her steak. This was a 22nd anniversary dinner for the wife and me, and it was certainly memorable, but for the wrong reasons. Although I complained to the management, there was almost no followup. more
Reply | Report abuse |

the colonel 10/20/2003

can be as comfortable as a corner bar or as formal as any place. With friends just fun and with clients very formal; a perfect mix, that keeps people coming back year after year. Pros: staff, prices, jazz Cons: hard to find for out- more
Reply | Report abuse |

Chuck 5/15/2003

I made a reservation a week in advance and got a table for 2 next to the kitchen door. the only thing I could see was the wall. I probably should not have stayed. Another time I dined here and a patron was letting their child run up and down the aisle next to our table. This was disruptive to our dining. I felt the manager should have asked the parents to correct their child.After these two incidents I have never returned. The prices are too high for this type of service. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Better than the rest 1/23/2003

Great service and a cozy atmosphere coupled with the best steak in town make for a perfect night out. The service is excellent, and the wine menu is very competent. All of these factors combine to make it the best restaurant in Columbus, hands down. However, the original one is the only one to bother with because the newer one in Dublin lacks the charm and food quality. Pros: Great steaks, Good wine list, Great ambience Cons: Sitting next fire =, hot, groups get loud more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 2 Next >
Menu for Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
Editorial

  • The Scene
    Dark and clubby with cocktail bars, this is where the over-30 crowd can feel at home. The dining rooms are comfortable, wooded and spiced with live jazz on the weekends. The bar...

  • 8/14/2003 Provided by Citysearch
Additional information
  • Hours: Mon. - Sun. 5pm - 10pm
  • Payments: Discover, American Express, Cash, Master Card, Visa, Diner's Club
  • Neighborhoods: Northwest Professional Plaza
badge