top 10

Gaetano's

Claim
marker

271 Main St
Stoneham, MA 02180

marker
(781) 279-0100
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Main categories:

Restaurants

,

Italian Restaurants

Related categories:

Food & Dining

,

European Restaurants

Photos
Gaetano's - Stoneham, MA
Gaetano's - Stoneham, MA
Gaetano's - Stoneham, MA
Gaetano's - Stoneham, MA
Gaetano's - Stoneham, MA
Gaetano's - Stoneham, MA
Gaetano's - Stoneham, MA
Reviews
( 11 )
( 0 )
( 1 )
( 0 )
( 4 )

Best

WOW

I went to gaetanos this past weekend with friends. We enjoyed some great drinks at the bar before sitting at a table for dinner. We got some appetizers first the Calamari was th...

Worst

Please don't bother. The food is mediocre at best, the service was not with a smile...neither the hostess nor the waitress. Mandatory 20% on large parties is fine only if the se...

Editorial review from Citysearch 10/12/2012

Never been before.. probably won't go back.. Food was ok.. service was VERY GRUMPY. And because we were 8 people we had an automatic 20%!!!!! added to the bill for gratuity. I typically tip 20%.. but for a waitress with an attitude problem.. I DON'T.\r This or any other eatery does not deserve the right to add an additional 20% for service that was mediocre at best.\r DISAPPOINTING SERVICE OVERALL. more

WOW 4/6/2010

I went to gaetanos this past weekend with friends. We enjoyed some great drinks at the bar before sitting at a table for dinner. We got some appetizers first the Calamari was the best and the lobster raviolis were so fresh. We split one of the extra large pizzas for dinner and i couldnt believe how big it was. there was 4 of us and the pizza was still left over at the end. Pros: Excellent Drinks, Outdoor seating, Cons: Not at this place more

A must try! 9/5/2008

I can not stop raving about this place. We went with four other couples and our children (27 people in total). The service as well as the hostess were outstanding! The food was terrific! What a variety as far as the food and have I mentioned the martinis - SPECTACULAR! I can't wait to go back! Parking is available in the back. Pros: Staff, parking more

My Big Fat Italian Restaurant! 9/2/2008

I came across Gaetano's a few years ago with a friend of mine, looking to have some food, drinks and conversation. We sat at the bar to eat. There are a good amount of regulars that go there, but they are all very friendly and the bartender was great. She introduced us to some of the other people sitting at the bar and it made for a really interesting and fun social night. I have been back many times and love the food and the atmosphere. Some of the regulars like to order food and share it with others at the bar...it is a very casual and friendly atmosphere. Some nights, it is like being at a big fat Italian wedding!! I have even brought my mom there and she had such a nice time. I like sitting at the bar, but I have also been to Gaetano's with a large party and had a great experience. I alway find parking either on the street or in the parking lot in the back. Some of my foodie favorites that I recommend are pizza, eggplant rollantini, fried calamari with hot peppers, fusilli with chicken and broccoli rabe, chicken parm and fillet mignon and definitely for cocktails, try an espresso martini or a harvest martini (fabulous!!!). The specials are sometimes to die for too!! All in all, I would highly recommend Gaetano's whether you have a large group or you go alone and eat at the bar. Pros: food, service, bartenders, drinks, wine Cons: have to wait sometimes for a table or a seat at the bar, but I guess that means others like it too. more

DO BOTHER! 8/31/2008

Please do bother. The food was excellent, their service could not have been any better. The hostess and waitress were very attentive and helpful. The cocktails were to die for. I will be coming there to dine again. more

Absolutely Bother!! 8/29/2008

I was inspired to write this review after reading a recent review ""don't bother"" which couldn't be further from the truth. My family and I visit Gaetano's on a regular basis with other couples and with large families. The service for both large groups and small groups is always above par. We brought first timers with us recently and they raved about the pizza and the quality of the meals. The cocktails and martinis are great as well! more

Best Italian Food North of Boston 8/29/2008

Our family eats here quite frequently due to it's extensive menu, fine service and excellent value. The waitstaff couldn't be friendlier. When we can't make it to the restaurant we order take out frequently and their pizza's are delicious. Try their buffalo or margherita pizza's. Highly recommend the restaurant to all my friends and family. Pros: menu, service, parking Cons: might have to wait so make a reservation more

Don't bother! 8/25/2008

Please don't bother. The food is mediocre at best, the service was not with a smile...neither the hostess nor the waitress. Mandatory 20% on large parties is fine only if the service is worth it. We were not advised of the policy beforehand. Restaurant is not group-friendly, but did not make me aware of that before I booked a reservation for 10 ppl. I understand about a group of 10 ppl being loud, and the possibility of being asked to tone it down, but the way in which this was conveyed to our group was demeaning and embarrassing. Cocktails were watered down and everyone made us feel so unwelcome. more

Great food and fabulous atmosphere and amazing martinis! 2/18/2008

I have gone to Gaetano's a few times and highly recomend it. After reading the reviews, I disagee with the thought that this place is club like. It can be loud/crowded on weekends but I take that to be a good sign. First of all... the italian cuisine is delicious and reasonably priced. The menu not only offers delicious italian meals ( my favorite is the lobster raviolis and fried calamari for apps) but the chef will make something like chicken fingers and freedom fries (my sons favorite).\r As far as the atmosphere.. I love it.. its like being in a fancy north end restaurant but then again its a family place... its perfect for everyone. I wasnt bothered by the fact many people seemed to know one another there... thats the appeal of it and thats what makes the experience so friendly. \r Over all...delicious food and wonderful restaurant. Plus... the martini selection is phenomenol and creative... and the wine pours are quite generous! Pros: Everything Cons: Nada more

You've got to be kidding me!! 7/12/2007

Well, I felt like this place was a total waste of money! We recently moved to the area and based on the great reviews, thought we would give it a shot. What a mistake! My husband's chicken parmesan wasn't fully cooked and my pasta dish was less than tasty. The service was also terrible- our waitress never came back to check on us after taking our order and we actually had to flag down a hostess to get us some water!! Don't waste your money- go somewhere else! more

Good food, bad atmosphere. 1/5/2007

I would recommend making a reservation, although I have never waited more than 20-30 minutes. We like to sit at the bar when we are at a restaurant while waiting for our table. The bar is small and there are never seats there because of the ""regulars"". I agree with the other people who mentioned the loudness. We don't go there much anymore because it seems like everyone else in the restaurant knows each other and it feels uncomfortable. The owner is very nice and the staff is good but the ""club"" feel keeps us away a lot of the time. We eat there more in the summer when you can sit outside. They do have delivery and we have food delivered from time to time but it would be nice to go out. The service is good, the food is excellent. The pizza is the best around and the eggplant rollantini is outstanding. Pros: Food is very good, service is good. Cons: No ambience, parking is hard.- more

Best Value North of Boston 2/24/2006

I look forward to going to Gaetano's at least twice a week because of its extensive menu, fine quality and excellent service. The friendly atmosphere is what also draws us here. Our children enjoy their pizza or pasta and their specials are great values. (We usually take home half of a meal.) The waitstaff couldn't treat us any better. In response to a few recent reviews about it being LOUD or letting themselves go, this is not so. Most people that go here return for a reason, ""GREAT FOOD & SERVICE WITH GOOD PRICES"". Pros: free parking, great value, large portions Cons: occas crowded more

User review by cappy128 2/23/2006

Gaetanos was very clean and neat with a friendly neighborhood atmosphere. The staff was courteous and prompt. The food was extremely good. Try the Mussels Fra Divalo or the Buffalo Chicken Pizza, amazing Pros: food, cleanliness more

User review by stepheddie 2/23/2006

Great food and fun place. I have been eating at this restaurant for 10 years now and I have always had great meals and excellent service. I have eaten at many restaurants and nothing compares to the food. Not to mention they give enormous portions so you have enough for lunch the next day. I highly recommend this restaurant. Pros: Great prices, Parking in rear, Attentive staff more

If you like LOUD 1/26/2006

Have been here twice. It seems like they have a crowd of regulars. Was seated at a table between two tables of ten people each, that felt compelled to shout back and forth to each other. More like a ""club"" then a restaurant. I mentioned to the waiter how rude it was. Can't blame the waiter for not saying anything. I addressed the people at the table and was given dirty looks through the meal. I do NOT recommend this restaurant based on this experience The food was average at best but. The total experience was not worth it more

They've really let themselves go... 1/23/2006

Went there for lunch on a Sunday. We were the only customers, but there were plenty of wait staff and kitchen staff loittering around. Our waitress was very nice and the food was ok, but what really ruined the experience was the lack of maintenance on the building. The carpets smelled damp, and while we ate, they sprayed the carpet right in front of us! I am left to wonder why they were spraying... Workers kept milling around and chatting before their shift started. Didn't really add to the whole experience. more

Great place to dine! 9/18/2002

Great restaurant! The atmosphere is beautiful, the patio is great on a summer night. The food was delicious! Pros: lovely atmosphere, great service Cons: small bar more
< Previous 1 Next >
Menu for Gaetano's


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
Additional information
  • Hours: Mon - Tue, 11:30am - 9pm; Wed, 11:30am - 10pm; Thu - Sat, 11:30am - 11am; Sunday, 4pm - 9pm
  • Payments: American Express, Discover, Master Card, Visa
badge