The best Restaurants in Oyster Bay are:

1. Bonanza Stand Of Oyster Bay

Rating: 4.8

Category: Carry Out

25 Shore Ave
Oyster Bay, New York 11771
(516) 922-7796

Some come back to OB for the legand of Teddy Roosevelt, but not I ! Have been coming back each yr for 30 yrs- and a trip to "chinks" as the locals... More

Guest

By:

Vote

2. Taby's

Rating: 4.5

Category: Restaurants

28 Audrey Ave
Oyster Bay, New York 11771
(516) 624-7781

Taby's is the best kept secret on the North Shore. The food is always fresh and piping hot. The burgers & fries are outrageous & their Greek salad... More

by BDSamstar at Citysearch

By:

Vote

3. The Homestead

Rating: 3.2

Category: Restaurants

107 South St
Oyster Bay, New York 11771
(516) 922-4305

Casual yet classy, warm and inviting, these are the adjectives that come to mind, and the most important one, delicious; I truly recommend this... More

by trueluminary at Citysearch

By:

Vote

4. Nino's Pizza

Rating: 5.0

Category: Pizza Restaurants

25 E Main St
Oyster Bay, New York 11771
(516) 922-0434

Pizza Nino is this tiny store located between a bar and a Subways. The pizza is thin and crisp with the right proportion of sauce, seasonings and... More

carol n.

By:

Vote

5. Bakery Cafe

Rating: 5.0

Category: Restaurants

124 South St
Oyster Bay, New York 11771
(516) 922-7002

The bacon is hot and crisp. They offer fresh squeezed orange juice and lemonade. Both are delicious. Friendly staff. Obsessed with this... More

by eyecandi at Citysearch

By:

Vote

6. Rite Aid

Rating: 5.0

Category: Beauty Salons

273 Pine Hollow Rd
Oyster Bay, New York 11771
(516) 624-7050

Rite Aid is convenient and has friendly floor staff. Good Pharmacy and decent prices. More

Guest

By:

Vote

7. Serata

Rating: 5.0

Category: Restaurants

160 Mill River Road, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
Oyster Bay, New York 11771
(516) 628-2800

What an experience! Excellent food! Fantastic movies and music!! A must try for all! (1) Meatballs: Nonna... More

by DLF at Menuism

By:

Vote

8. Homestead Restaurant

Rating: 5.0

Category: Restaurants

107 South St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
Oyster Bay, New York 11771
(516) 624-7410

BAND WAS MOVING VIOLATIONS THEY WERE GREAT!! FOOD WAS GREAT..DRINKS GREAT..PLACE CLEAN..HIGHLY RECOMMEND! More

sandyshaw

By:

Vote

9. Mario's Pizza

Rating: 4.0

Category: Restaurants

Pine Hollow Rd
Oyster Bay, New York 11771
5 (126) 922-9111

Marios makes many, many different types of pizza. It is thick and hearty- one slice may be enough for most people. I personally think that their... More

carol n.

By:

Vote

10. La Stella II Pizzeria

Rating: 4.0

Category: Restaurants

342 Lexington Ave
Oyster Bay, New York 11771
(516) 922-2023

La Stella has great food! It has about 10 tables or you can order to go. Thier manigotti tastes like it is made with fresh pasta. Their chicken... More

carol n.

By:

Vote