I am a local resident who has never stayed overnight or dined at the Plumbush Inn. Its food is reputed to be good, but pricey. I once put a guest up at the Inn. I was mortified when he phoned to say he was staring at a recycled breakfast. I rushed over and it appeared to be so. There was no one in charge to speak with. I brought my guest home for a decent meal. The next day I drove to the Inn, and again there was no one to speak with. Needless to say, I have never returned.
more