I have had pizza at this place 5 times since it opened. Not one of those pizza's was what I would consider good pizza. Cheap-o ingredients and terrible crust that tastes like a freezer burned cardboard box. The last pizza was so bad that I will never eat at Geraldi's again, which is too bad because they really do have nice folks working there and I like nothing more than seeing business succeed in North Plains. Those who would call Geraldi's pizza "decent" perhaps have never had real pizza made with high quality ingredients, such as Hot Lips or Flying Pie or the recently closed Merchant of Venice in Hillsboro. People who understand what makes pizza great should avoid Geraldi's. Since Geraldi's is the only pizza joint in town I guess you could call it "the best pizza in North Plains" but you could also call it the worst pizza in North Plains.
more