I love Time After Time for vintage clothing and accessories. Every time I go in there, I find tons of stuff I want to buy--like a whole bunch of leather jackets for about $7 this past spring.
You can depend on Time After Time for costumes, too. Especially for a retro-themed party, definitely go there first!
Plus, it's such a convenient location, right on Franklin Street--if you don't find something there (unlikely) you can just go to another thrift store down the street!
more