Call up the Re-Store. They have heaps of salvaged old house parts, more cool stuff than you can believe. And their non-profit. Also call up the other great house salvage joints in town, SeattleBuilding Salvage, Earthwise (down on 1st ave south), and Second Use (down near white center in a hard to find place). If you call those guys up, at least one of them probably has old house numbers.
And the old place we rented actually had some cool old tin ones that were cheap that they had gotten at Anthopologie.
If all else fails, check out the offerings at VanDyke's Restorers online at www.vandykes.com.
Good luck
more