I order frequently from Wings Over Madison. It's not gourmet, but it's consistent, it's delivered on time, there's variety (in sauces), and ordering from there generally makes me happy. The wings come in a mind-numbing number of sauces, too many, I've ordered enough that I have some favorites but it's really a paradox of choice. Suggestion: name them after a key ingredient so we get an idea, e.g. Honey Mustard is useful, Cruising Altitude, not so much... The honey bar-b-que ribs are good enough to eat every night. The Buffalo Chicken Sandwich is another consistent, satisfying winner. Despite the fact this food can't possibly be healthy, it doesn't seem fatty. That is, I don't feel sluggish or like crawling into a fetal position after eating it.
This isn't the kind of food to share on a date, and it won't impress your inlaws, but it's pretty darn reliably good for the price and an easy go to option for frequent take-out orders.
more