I had gone to Eataly when it first opened and it was quite good. I returned with friends this past weekend and was very disappointed. We tried the fish and seafood station first. The first fish we ordered was a bad piece of snapper with a large dark area in the flesh and it was overcooked to the point of being rubbery. We sent it back and tried the grouper which was completely raw in the middle. The manager and cook both apologized, but did not even offer us a free glass of wine. We then went to the cheese and salami area and were given three dirty plates. The marble counter we were sitting out was stained and dirty. Everyone who works there seems very young. For the price range, this place needs to put some experience on the floor as oversight. We won't be going back.
more