I grew up in Baldwinsville and eat at Atlantic Seafood whenever I go home. Take-out places don't stay in business for decades when all the food is horrible, as one reviewer characterized it. That reviewer stated: ""The fish was horrible and way over cooked and dry as a bone. Also very greasy."" How fried fish can be both 'dry' AND 'greasy' is beyond me; those are opposites. That's such nonsense that it makes me wonder whether a competitor wrote the review. Or someone with a vendetta against the owners. NB: This fish IS cooked thoroughly and not half way to sashimi.
more