For the last 6 years, my wife and I have been going to Claudios at least once each summer. Actually, it wasn't until year 3 that we realized that it was kind of our tradition to do so. Each time we go, we reminisce (or try to... the older we get the harder it is to remember) about what we ordered the year before, it's great.
In all the years that we've gone, we leave each time saying WOW that was probably the best... but to our surprise, the next time always seems to taste better than what we remembered of the time before.
I have no specific recommendations - try it all.... we've yet to be disappointed (although, the mussels are always a great way to start any meal, right?)
more