We live about 30 minutes from Blue Sky and it has been one of my favorite places to grab a fun lunch over the years. It has a Key West/Jimmy Buffet vibe to it. My husband and I drove out there today specifically to enjoy a lunch there. On the specials board were many meals listed and my husband was immediately attracted to the one that said ""Fish Tacos, whitefish"" and i to ""shrimp tacos."" When our meals were delivered first we noticed a dollop of sour cream on top, which is not that out of the ordinary for a taco, which as it turned out was a soft taco. We both scraped the sour cream off and thought that would be it. then we each took a bite of our tacos and realized the fish/shrimp was bathed in sour cream, truly disgusting and unexpected. I have never ordered any kind of taco anywhere where the sour cream was mixed throughout the taco. My husband took his back inside to tell them he did not want sour cream in his and this man was obviously quite angry about it. He came back out and told me about it. Then as i tried to eat mine not wanting to take our second back in, i couldn't do it, so i ended up taking mine in too. My husband and I decided that we would just pay for new meals even though we thought it was not our responsibility to know sour cream was in it. When i took mine in the woman told me that of course they had sour cream in them, ""they are California tacos."" Well i had to laugh, as i mentioned the theme of the restaurant is Key West not California. the items were not listed as ""California tacos"" just fish/shrimp tacos. So when i offered to pay for our new tacos sans the sour cream, she actually charged me another $20 for it as if it was our fault. Unbelievable!! We will not be returning! They could not have been more rude or unfair about it. I would never run a business like that.
Pros: fun atmosphere
Cons: terrible customer service and food not great
more