I've been ordering from Trophy Depot for the past 3 years after switching from another big trophy shop - listen:
1) low price guarantee they HONOR 100% of the time
2) selection - they have something like 80 column choices and dozens of ribbons for medals, get exactly what you want for your team
3) free ship above $95 - also great deals on rush shipping if you're in a bind
4) customer service is open super late year round if you need help or have questions
Free catalogs too and they email you awesome coupons year round. Check 'em out for your next trophy and awards order.
Pros: personalized service, low price guarantee
Cons: can't think of any
more