I live around the corner from this restaurant and frequent many brooklyn restaurants. The food here is exceptional, the wine prices are reasonable, and the service and atmosphere are outstanding. I've CONSISTENTLY experience quality service and food at Anthony's.
The prices are reasonable (this IS New York City) and the portion is appropriate (as another poster wrote, if you want massive portions move back to Missouri).
I LOVE Anthony's and I have eaten here every other week for almost 3 years.
Pros: Fantastic food, great service, exceptional atmosphere
Cons: absolutely none
more