Went to the New York Oven for the first time with my family and was shocked when I opened the menu to see the average price of a meal was around $18. The inside and outside of the restaurant reflect a reasonably priced family restaurant. The marquee said 2 pizzas for 19.99. The decor and ambiance of the restaurant is not worthy of such prices. When we asked the waitress if we could order pizza she brought us a different menu and gave us an attitude of disdain. We were given cheap plastic plates while a table near us eating dinners were served on a much nicer plates. Yes, we weren't paying as much but it was not very classy. We had to ask for napkins and silverware. I will say that the pizza was good but I can almost guarantee that this restaurant will never make it in Dillsburg unless varying price options are offered and the restaurant is redesigned to offer a classier atmosphere.
Pros: Pizza was good
Cons: Price
more