Paul at Classic Honda is the man. You might not immediately guess it from his humble shop which is tucked away in a side street of Santa Cruz, but he is one of the best (if not the best) mechanics I've ever encountered. He's everything I stated in the 'pros' section and more. Don't ever go anywhere else, especially if you own a late model Honda - he's an expert.
Pros: Honest, reliable, knowledgeable, enthusiastic
Cons: Haven't found any yet
more