I have to admit for 1st time for me to go to City Island and trying Sammy's I was not disappointed. However, I did not care for traffic, you definitely need a lots of patience. But I got there I was seated with no wait ( I went there at 5pm to avoid large crowds), I was attended by friendly service. Very nice atmosphere. I like the place. I wish it was located somewhere more easier to get to. It is such a nice restaurant located in not so nice neighborhood. It's very overcrowded island with not much more than eateries. I would definitely like to visit there again, if it was much easier to get to and less traffic. Price is little high, but they give you plenty of tasty food, price is justified by the amount of food and good taste. I recommended it for who like to eat large portion of great seafood and does not mind driving long way in slow traffic..
Pros: Great service, large portions and taste great
Cons: Traffic, hard to get to.
more