I've been to A&P arms several times. Despite having a large staff the workers seemed overwhelmed with the sheer volume of customers.
Having to wait for assistance was the only detractor from my experience there though. The staff I talked to genuinely seemed informed about the products, were friendly and gave me good advice.
The person that helped me pick out my 1911 even gave me a card for a person who makes custom gun leather rather than trying to sell me a generic holster from their store.
It's a great store if you don't mind waiting.
Pros: Excellent service, good variety of firearms and supplies.
Cons: Extremely busy/crowded.
more