We only started ordering a few months ago, but since we discovered that they are part of GrubHub, we haven't ordered from any other italian place in town.
Pizza is excellent. Salads are excellent, too. The french fries are the best that can be delivered in New Paltz. Not a fan of the garlic knots, but otherwise, EVERYTHING has been good. We've ordered quite a few different items from almost every section of their menu.
They're very friendly on the phone and when they deliver!
more