My family has been going to Hershey Auto for as long as we've lived in the area. He's by far one of the best mechanics I've known. His prices are slightly higher than the competition, but he's by far the most skilled and knowledgeable mechanic I've ever known.
Pros: Absolutely amazing with cars, fast, reliable, and run by a good natured guy
Cons: Prices are a tad higher than other mechanics
more