This place is great if you want excellent food at very reasonable prices. We were sick of the chain restaurants and after trying Village Gourmet, we celebrate most of our special occasions there. The place is cozy, so you may or may not like it; I find it charming. Because of Rutherford's BYOB rule, the in-house wine store is convenient but ironic. Only 1/2 complaint is that there is one waitress we cross our fingers not to get. All other waitstaff has been friendly and attentive.
Pros: Warm & Cozy Atmosphere, In-house Wine Store
Cons: One Bad Waitress Who is Always There
more