Lived on the island all my life, been to Alley's and every other store on the island, and ally's is not one of worst. While prices do tend to hover a bit above the rest, the typically native islander staff is always helpful and willing to lend a hand. They are very good about handling specialty orders, that is, anything they do not carry, they'll get if you ask. I wouldn't hold much confidence in a person who said they went to ally's at the end of july (height of the summer) and find it to be not very busy. They near always have a full house. God forbid a coffee lid doesn't fit, i am quite certain this individual exaggerated much in their description. I would suggest anyone curious about Alley's to definitely check it out, and immerse yourself in a real island store, and ignore the blatant ignorance of the first reviewer.
Pros: Friendly Staff, Great Variety
Cons: Pricey
more