I had a very good experience with Kwicksilver and would highly recommend them. I had severe curb rash on one of my aluminum rims and they were very quick on the repair and did a wonderful job. I checked a few places beforehand to compare prices and convenience and settled on Kwicksilver, and I wasn't dissappointed. And yes, i would go back.
Pros: Quick turnaround; they keep in contact
Cons: May cost as much as just replacing the rim, so be aware
more