I love Superfine! I don't even live in Brooklyn, but go there regularly, ever since attending their amazing Halloween party last year. It seems like my friends and I always end up there. It's funky and bohemian, but the food is top-notch. It's really fresh - local farmers provide mostly organic produce - though they still have decadent stuff like home-made bourbon ice cream and great burgers. i also love the scallops and turbot salad. It's one of the few places left in DUMBO where you won't get attitude, and I love that they have live music at Sunday brunch. They have a great bar scene and a pool table with lots of lounge seating around it, though neither are too close to the dining area. All around, my favorite place unless I need to go super-fancy. They also have lots of performance events and cool theme parties.
Pros: awesome food, friendly atmoshere, nice and mellow bar scene, live music
Cons: it's in brooklyn, though it's close to the F and A/C
more