I go for the pies. They're fantastic, probably better than they need to be, really, and good and hot. I see other diners have commented on the rudeness of the staff. I've never experienced this, nor have I ever been anything other than happy with my interactions. Perhaps being pleasant-looking and polite helps. Dessert, too, (esp. the bread-and-butter pudding) is essential, if you can fit it.
Pros: pies; desserts; possibly the smallest bathroom in the city
Cons: sometimes you will have to wait
more