I've been to Melillo's alot, since it a good, unpretentious, family-run Italian restaurant. I highly recommend their lasagna and chicken parmesan sandwich. Both are extremely good. Beware of their soup and salads - the are good and are HUGE servings! Go early to make sure you don't have to wait for a table, since the place is fairly small. I believe they are closed on Mondays.
Pros: Good food, Comfortable but nice atmosphere, Parking lot
Cons: Small inside seating, Can be a wait
more