We brought in our car to have a tire replaced; Their selection of used tires was reasonable and all only lightly used. In any case, they let us pick out the one we wanted, so we decided to go with one of the exact same name brand/model as the ones with which our car had come equipped (only newer). $40 and 10 minutes later, we were on the road and happy as clams. Not bad, compared to a new tire at 90-100 bucks elsewhere and 150 at our car dealer! One bit of warning: the tires don't come with warranties, though they said we should just bring the car back if we have any difficulties.
Pros: Friendly, quick service, low price
Cons: No warranty, place could be cleaned up a bit
more