Many years ago, I took my son to this restaurant to celebrate him getting his driver's licence. The food was good and we enjoyed our lunch. I was very sad when it closed. Hearing that it reopened, my son and his family decided to surprise my husband and I with an anniversary dinner at the newly opend restaurant. It was a wonderful meal and the building looked beautiful. We enjoyed it so much that we decided to go back as a family for Thanksgiving. We were lucky to get in as they were booking up fast. Our meals were wonderful, especially the prime rib, which according to my husband is the best he has ever had. I was a little nontraditional and chose the Halibut. It was delicious ( I loved the crispy polenta and the yummy sauce), as far as I am concerned it is the best halibut in town. The Turkey dinners, had by the rest of the family, got rave reviews. It was a wonderful way to spend Thankgiving, no stress, great food and service and of course NO DISHES!! Everyone should do this! This is definately not the same Sheepherder restaurant of yester year, it is better! Thanks to Justin for the delcious Buena Vista and thanks to Ralph for his attentive service. We will be back year after year after year.
Pros: Wonderful atmosphere, drinks, appetizers and food.
Cons: Would have loved the fireplaces to be lit
more