If you want tender fillet mignon rather than chewy porterhouse, this one is not for you. If you want romantic diner with candle light rather than noise cheap wooden table, this one is not for you. If you like well cooked rather than bloody rare, this one is not for you.\r
\r
I have read couple of complaints about their service recently and I agree with them. Their service was terrible and it is getting worse. I am usually annonied by waiters' bossy attitute also. But they are nice to Jewish neighbor customers \r
.\r
Even based on all of these, I do not hesitate to vote this one as #1 steak in NY. Their hot, bloody, oily, rare potterhouse is too tempting to ingore them.\r
\r
If you really hate Peter Luger service but cannot resist their food, I would recommend Wolfgang's as an alternative. Because of trivial reason, Wolfgang provides almost as good steak as Peter Luger. I would not say the food is better, but Wolfgang has 10 times better interior and service is slightly better.
Pros: Best Poterhouse
Cons: Service
more