It was our anniversary although the waitress didn't know it. It was very nice..low lighting and romantic. They take reservations and called to confirm. The food was good and the waitress was attentive and seemed to know we were celebrating something because she made a nice show of pouring the champagne. We stayed a long time after we paid the check. Will always come back.
Pros: Beautiful view of Manhattan, good food, attentive staff
Cons: may have to park in surrounding shopping area and walk a bit
more