I just went to Sheridan's Frozen Custard and its the best thing I've ever tasted! Even though they only carry vanilla and chocolate (which are sooooooo good!), they can create any flavor you are looking for! Even Cotton Candy! They had great customer service and it is resonably priced. I would definately check this place out.
Pros: Ambience is nice with an oldies theme from back in New York
Cons: Only a walk up, no indoor seating
more