I suppose Sardella's received such a high review because Newport does not have many Italian Restaurants. I have to say during the winter it is very nice to sit next to the fireplace and eat your meal (which I have) however the meals just do not do it for me. The portions are small and the red italian sauce is too sweet, almost tasting like something you purchase out of a can. The prices can be a bit high (well that is Newport) and when it is crowded it gets really loud. Parking can be difficult especially in the summer.
Pros: Fireplace in the Winter, Reservations
Cons: Parking, Food, Loudness
more