Last night was my 3rd time dinning at Peter Luger (Brooklyn) and I've been to the one in Great Neck once. Now it's time for me to give my unbias opinion. Sorry but I have to say that this restaurant is definitely overrated. I called three weeks in advance to get a table for a Wednesday night. The steak was bland and overly burned on the outside. The German baked potatoes was so burned that we could hardly bite into it. I gave this restaurant 3 chances and none of them was up to my expectation. I would rather go to Outback instead. Also, believe it or not, steaks at the Great Neck location are a lot more tasty, and it's easier to get a reservation with them. I never mind paying the price for quality food, but I am totally done with them and will never go back again.
more