JavaScript is not enabled.
Very overrated - Review by citysearch c | Carl Anthony's Trattoria

Carl Anthony's Trattoria

Claim

Very overrated 12/15/2006

When this place first opened, it was fabulous. Since being back last year, I was not impressed with how the place had changed. The dishes were downright odd, many of them did not even sound appetizing, and the prices were very high. What I did end up ordering was average at best. I also had a bad experience on my mother's birthday...I had a reservation for 10 people and called that day to find out if I could bring my own cake...they at first gave me a hard time, but then gave in, only after demanding that I pay a ridiculous cutting charge of like $5/plate or something outrageous like that. Obviously accomodating their customers (with a party of 10, the check would have been pretty nice, much better than their stupid cutting charge) and ensuring they get repeat business is not that important to them, as after they refused to budge I cancelled my reservation and moved my dinner party to Roberto's up the street and have not been back. Pros: Good desserts Cons: Everything else more
Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021