We have stayed here three or four times, even though we live just across the river. The location is perfect, the bartenders in Pazzo are friendly, the front desk staff is always helpful and down-to-earth. I highly recommend the Hotel Vintage Plaza -- try one of the Graden Suites with the cedar balcony and outdoor hot tub! It's totally worth it. One thing -- if you're shy, bring your bathing suit, because people in the nearby highrises can see right into your balcony! Made for a good laugh on Christmas Night, nekkid in downtown P-town.
Pros: location, friendly service, Pazzo
Cons: smaller rooms, parking
more