The review saying Sloppy Joe's was not Hemingway's fav bar and that Captain Tony's was is a half truth. SJ's was located around the corner from it's current location when Ernest drank there (where Tony's currently sits). It was however Sloppy Joe's bar that he drank at. As far as the bar itself, know what to expect going in... It's crowded, noisey, a little expensive, and not all the food is gourmet. However, it's also one of the most fun places on the island, guaranteed to have a great time when Pete and Wayne are playing (very R-rated). Good music, good company, and good drinks make up for a lot in my book. Also, to all of the food critics out there, try the Sloppy Fries and Grouper Sandwich next time, excellent!
Pros: Music (Pete & Wayne), Atmosphere, Grouper/Sloppy Fries
Cons: Slightly Expensive, No seats sometimes, Daytime cruise crowds
more